Tax strategy

International Tax Review is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Garden, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2026

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement


Tax strategy

By Andreas Staubli, PricewaterhouseCoopers, Switzerland

The way a company manages its tax affairs on the world-wide basis is directly relevant to its shareholders. Both the tax charge as well as the tax risks taken have a direct impact on the accounts and therefore on the valuation of a company.

A wider awareness of corporate governance issues including tax matters, an increased complex international tax legislation environment as well as governments and tax authorities trying to protect their tax revenues by tightening rules and improving their approach to tax collection and enforcement are forcing companies to have and operate a clear tax strategy. A tax strategy shall support the objectives of the business and it should drive decision-making. Such a tax strategy has to be formally documented and be formally adopted by the board.

What is a tax strategy?

A tax strategy means an outline of what the tax function has to achieve and the plan for getting there, starting from the current position. The tax strategy is the starting point for setting objectives and priorities, and then for negotiating and allocating resources accordingly. And it is about formalizing, agreeing and communicating a tax strategy within a company.

Some of the benefits are:

  • senior management including the board confirms that the tax strategy aligns with the business strategy;

  • the tax framework with its goals and responsibilities is clearly defined and it helps raise the profile of tax issues and pushes tax higher up senior management's agenda;

  • it serves as a useful basis for communication with the executive, the tax function, business staff and external advisers;

  • re-visiting the strategy on a regular basis provides for a progress measurement and forces management to be dynamic and responsive to changes in the tax and other relevant business environment; and

  • the tax department organization and reporting lines becomes aligned to the formulated tax strategy.

The key driver behind a tax strategy and consequently its designer will always be the head of tax since he needs a map as to where he is taking the tax function. The rest of the tax team, including the overseas tax function and business tax staff, have to contribute to ensure a common understanding and for motivational reasons. The chief financial officer will usually have high level input into the strategy design and use it as a framework in making tax-related decisions and in monitoring how the tax department is performing. The discussion of the tax strategy with the board, in our experience, provides sometimes for a different view and it adds senior backing to the tax function's approach.

Additional important contributors are external advisers providing for best practice input, operational people, legal and compliance, risk management people and other departments.

Principles in developing a tax strategy

There are lots of areas that could be addressed in a tax strategy and, of course, this varies from company to company. It might include effective accounting tax rate, cash tax rate, competitor tax rates, tax risks, tax compliance, corporate structure, ethics, reputation with tax authorities and with public, key tax drivers, tax department organization, corporate structure, capital structure, resourcing and resource costs, use of advisers, indirect tax, operational tax matters, human resource tax, performance measurement and many things more.

However, a tax department has to decide which of these sometimes competing factors are actually its top priorities – and thus put some focus into where its resources are best used. And this will change over time since the tax strategy should be dynamic and responsive to change.

A true tax strategy should set out the goals, outline the route-map for achieving them, be clear as to the timeframe and set out responsibilities. Good objectives will provide the milestones against which effort to achieve the aims of the tax strategy can be measured. The classic test of effective objective setting is whether they are SMART, in that they are specific, measurable, achievable, results-oriented and timely.

Most important is that the strategy needs to be lived or put into practice. Measurement of the achievement against the objectives by management and regular communication with the board are key to making a visible difference.

The role of the tax function

We have seen a significant number of the tax functions whose view of their role differs from the perspective of other departments and senior management. For example, is the tax function fully responsible for operational tax matters or only acting as an adviser to another department? Typical areas of different views are human resource tax matters and indirect taxes such as customs duty and value-added tax (VAT).

Consequently, a clear definition of roles and responsibilities of the tax function and its communication is important to avoid misunderstandings and ensure that the tax function can effectively focus on its strategy and meet expectations. The role of the tax function can be split into four dimensions: strategic planning work, operational/business support, compliance/accounting work and management of the tax function and its resources. And for each dimension, the activities and the responsibilities have to be defined. However, the tax function cannot deal with all its activities with the same level of attention but rather has to define and agree on areas of focus and priorities.

The next three sections focus on the three areas a tax function can control and which are the key elements of a tax strategy document. These are the tax charge, tax risk and the costs of managing the tax position. And clearly, there is a strong link between these three elements.

Managing the tax charge

The main focus of senior management still is on the accounts tax charge and the impact it has on earnings per share. However, we also see increasingly interest in the cash tax rate as well as in the overall tax contribution.

Corporate income taxes are typically the core business of a tax function. Above the line taxes such as value-added tax, import and excise duties, and (increasingly) environmental levies are of course also taxes on the business. The above/below the line question is particularly pertinent when agreeing respective responsibilities between the tax function and the businesses. We are aware of a number of significant sized businesses where even very senior management is rewarded on a profit-before-tax (PBT) measurement – including, more often than expected, the head of tax. This is hardly conducive to proactive management of the tax charge.

Who shall be the owner of the tax charge? If it is the responsibility of business managers to manage the tax charge, then it is more likely that the tax function will act as a service provider to the businesses, albeit hopefully as a fairly pro-active service provider. The tax function may also need to take on a role of central coordinator, ensuring consistency between the various businesses and perhaps encouraging the businesses through monitoring and publicizing their respective tax performance.

If the tax function owns the tax charge then more of a leadership role will be called for, with the tax function taking responsibility for driving tax performance in all the businesses. In today's reality, it is typically a mixture of the two. There is a trend though, in that the increasing move towards global management of businesses is reflected in a trend towards stronger head office tax function control of overseas tax affairs.

However, in companies where VAT or other indirect taxes are a significant cost these taxes are often given either to the businesses or to local tax functions. As a consequence, we often find that the management of such taxes suffers from a lack of co-ordination between different territories.

The tax charge of a company is a significant cost element. Getting senior management to focus on tax as a manageable component of shareholder value can be a powerful way to raise the profile of tax in the business. Often, the first time senior management really think deeply about the impact of tax is when they become involved in helping set the tax strategy.

Some elements of the tax charge are obviously going to be more manageable than others. Therefore, understanding the key manageable components of the tax charge, and then managing the related drivers will be key.

Managing the tax charge has also a time dimension. The tax function has to focus on negotiating prior years' tax liabilities, computing the current year's liability (including compliance, transfer pricing documentation, tax accounting and tax process management) as well as managing future liabilities.

Many businesses do not enough focus on the latter, that is, they are not proactively planning their tax charge.

When designing a tax strategy document, three to five objectives that work as focus areas for managing the tax charge should be agreed upon within the organization and with top management.

Managing tax risk

Uncontrolled or unidentified risk is clearly undesirable, but there will be occasions when a head of tax has to and even will want to take calculated risks. Entrepreneurial behaviour is about taking risks and managing tax is no different.

One can distinguish the following main tax-risk areas which are all interlinked with each other:

  • Transaction risk – risk arising from transactions and tax planning activity (where there can be considerable opportunity). The more unusual and less routine a particular transaction is, then generally, the greater the tax risks associated with the transaction are likely to be. In addition, improper implementation is a typical source of additional downside risks.

  • Operational risk – risk arising from the operations of the business units and the extent to which their activities may give rise to unexpected fluctuations in the tax charge.

  • Financial accounting risk and tax process risk - risk of materially incorrect accounts and lack of management controls over tax processes.

  • Compliance risk – risk of additional liabilities or penalties arising through non-compliance or failures in the tax return process.

Risks can lead to surprises, restatement of accounts, material weaknesses in processes, significant additional tax charges, interest, penalties and harmed reputation. A tax function should try to minimize and optimize interlinked with the objectives in the areas of managing the tax charge and managing the costs of the tax function.

Again the tax strategy document should focus on three to five risk areas that will get high tax management attention and set objectives. Since managing tax risk is so diverse and important, a structured tax risk management approach is highly recommended and that is in line with the trend we see. What is meant by a structured tax risk management approach? The starting point is the development of a tax-risk policy and in particular the definition of the risk appetite in the various tax risk areas. Of course this has to be discussed and agreed on with senior management and the board.

In a second step, a risk assessment should be made which results in a risk map and a plan for managing the key risks.

The third step is the design or review or implementation/remediation of the internal controls over tax processes relevant for managing the key tax risks.

Next is a communication plan to ensure the appropriate knowledge and information exchange on these matters within the organization.

The fourth step is monitoring and reporting, which typically is a combined effort of internal audit and tax function.

And last, management has to regularly review the tax risk policy and the tax risk appetite.

Managing the cost of the tax function

The cost of the tax function is made up of the core tax function, the shadow tax function (staff in other departments which do direct and indirect tax work), adviser's fees and senior management time. There is a correlation between the costs of managing tax and the ability to manage both the tax charge and the tax risks. When seeking to control the cost of managing the group's tax affairs, it is important to distinguish between measures to improve efficiency and measures which reduce the level of service the tax function delivers.

Nobody is going to argue against improved efficiency, but the level of cost of the tax function has to be set at such level, that the set objectives for managing the tax charge and the tax risks can be achieved. Having a proper tax strategy in place will help to ensure that the tax function receives the appropriate level of resource and that the business gets value for money from the tax function.

Tax department organization

Another important element of a tax strategy is the organization of the tax department. This largely depends on the tax charge strategy as well as the tax risk policy. The tax function has to be aligned to the set objectives. Generally, there is a choice between a head office model and a business unit/legal entity/country model. As mentioned earlier, the trend is toward the head office model but the structure needs to fit the requirements of both the business and the key tax issues that the tax function wants to manage.

The organization should specifically include the shadow tax function staff based in other areas of the business and also external tax resources. Different businesses use very different mixes of in-house, shadow and external tax resource. It is of utmost importance that the relationship with shadow staff and procedures for engaging external resource will need to be addressed when planning the tax function structure.

Another important element is the clear guidance on the reporting lines. In most cases the tax function will be allied with the finance function, but sometimes tax sits with the legal department. Historically, tax staff in overseas subsidiaries has normally reported to their local chief financial officers, albeit with dotted line reporting to the global head of tax. However as the trend towards global management grows, direct reporting to the global head of tax is on the increase.

Managing the tax team

A critical success factor is the managing of the tax team. Key is to ensuring appropriate focus of the tax team aligned with the tax strategy. Individual objective settings, job descriptions and formal staff evaluation systems are a useful discipline in keeping individuals focused on the overall tax strategy. There is a need for a balance of group and local measurable objectives aligned with the tax strategy as part of the performance measurement system.

The right skill set of the members of the tax function is of course a key factor too. Strong technical skills will constitute a basic requirement, but other softer business skills will prove crucial if the tax function is to be effective in actually managing the tax charge and risks.

Tax functions have come a long way from the days when only tax technical skills were considered important. Apart from soft skills mentioned, additional technical know-how is required in new areas like accounting, reporting, business operations (value chain and transfer pricing), risk management and process management. This leads to the crucial need to maintain and develop expertise and talents in a tax function. Therefore, providing internal and external training on a regular basis for technical matters (tax, accounting, risk management, Sarbanes-Oxley 404), developing soft skills as well as job rotations for new talent development and exposure to international tax issues are important elements of any tax strategy.

Stakeholder engagement and communication

However strong the skills of the tax team, it is unlikely to perform effectively if it does not manage its relationships with the senior management and the business properly. This will involve regular, quality communication. Therefore part of the tax strategy should be a section addressing how the tax function will maintain effective regular communication with management, the businesses and other key stakeholders and information providers. The more effective tax teams spend a good deal of their time out of their offices ensuring regular, high quality communication.

Appropriate attention

In an environment where regulatory and reporting requirements are getting tighter, where "unethical" tax planning is a topic of public discussion (driven by tax authorities), where the international tax environment gets more and more complex, where non-compliance leads to financial (penalties) and damage to the company's reputation, where the awareness for managing the tax charge to increase shareholder value has increased, where risk awareness and the need to manage the risks proactively has emerged with respect to tax in particular, having a formalized and communicated tax strategy is a must under today's corporate governance practice.

It is best practice to formalize a tax strategy in a comprehensive way and to develop the strategy involving the different stakeholders. Discussing the areas of focus with respect to managing the tax charge, deciding on the risk appetite and managing the risks as well as aligning the tax department organization and costs to the objectives set are the key elements of a tax strategy.

On the basis of a communication plan, the tax function has to keep the tax strategy up to date, in particular through regular feedbacks to senior management and board as well as discussions with them. Tax has become a strategic issue and therefore it needs the appropriate attention.

Biography

staubli-taxman06.jpg

 

Andreas Staubli

PricewaterhouseCoopers

Birchstrasse 160

8050 Zurich

Switzerland

Tel: +41 58 792 44 72

Fax: +41 58 792 44 10

Email: andreas.staubli@ch.pwc.com

Andreas Staubli has been an international corporate tax partner with PricewaterhouseCoopers since 2000. He leads the Swiss and Continental European insurance tax practice of PricewaterhouseCoopers. Andreas Staubli is a certified Swiss tax expert and graduated from the University of St.Gallen with a degree in finance and accounting. He gained his international tax experience during his secondment to the European Tax Planning Group of PricewaterhouseCoopers in New York in 1999/2000. Andreas Staubli is the lead tax partner for several multinationals and he specializes in international tax structuring, insurance taxation, alternative investment taxation matters as well as tax accounting (US GAAP and IFRS) and SOX 404.

Andreas Staubli is the author of various articles on tax matters and a frequent speaker at presentations on various tax topics.

more across site & shared bottom lb ros

More from across our site

From tax research to return preparation, firms should experiment with tax-specific AI applications rather than wait for the technology or their strategies to mature
Increasingly complex reporting and tax requirements were cited by the firm as an enduring driver of demand
A&M Tax is continuing its global expansion drive as it builds a broader full-service offering to challenge the big four
KPMG's UK head of tax policy discusses what the Budget means for businesses, whether pillar two has survived its US carve-out, and why taxing wealth could become the next global debate
The appointments of Thomas Gaughan and Daniel Martinez further signal that the private client advisory market is booming
The rebrand, which MHA said would make its connection to the Baker Tilly network ‘clear’, will take effect in February
The stars of Weil’s heavyweight tax practices are up for grabs, but recruiting firms will need to be patient to secure a package deal
Meta has overtaken Amazon as the ‘Silicon Six’ business with the worst tax conduct, according to the Fair Tax Foundation
Awards
It was also a memorable night for Baker McKenzie and its associated firms, after picking up 19 awards, including the coveted Asia-Pacific Tax Law Firm of the Year
Stocche Forbes Advogados, Utumi Advogados and Lobo de Rizzo Advogados have reached Tier 2 as competition intensifies in the region’s largest tax market
Gift this article