In a March 4 2004 decision, the ECJ held that France's taxation of certain types of foreign-source investment income is incompatible with the EC Treaty (case C-334/02, Commission v. France). Under French tax law, individuals receiving interest income from domestic capital investments can opt
to apply a final levy that is normally lower than the rates of ordinary income tax. This option is not available if the interest income is derived from foreign sources.
The European Commission had concluded that this rule is not in line with the EC Treaty and brought an infringement procedure against France before the ECJ. The ECJ agreed, holding that the tax treatment is discriminatory and it infringes articles 49 and 56 of the EC Treaty.
In the ECJ's view, the disparate treatment of payments according to the location of the debtor discourages taxpayers from contracting with foreign financial service providers and therefore violates the freedom to provide services and the free movement of capital principles.
The ECJ rejected the French government's argument that the restrictions were justified on the grounds of prevention of tax avoidance and the need for effective fiscal supervision.
ECJ reinforces protection under EC law
The ECJ held on January 13 2004 that national authorities must review final administrative decisions to take account of new ECJ case law (case C-453/00, Kühne & Heitz NV).
Such an obligation exists where:
the national authorities under national law have the authority to reopen administrative decisions;
the administrative decision has become final as a result of a national court decision ruling at first instance;
the national court decision is based on a misinterpretation of EC law and was issued without requesting a preliminary ruling from the ECJ and a subsequent (favourable) decision was rendered by the ECJ in a similar case; and
the aggrieved party filed a complaint with the relevant administration immediately after becoming aware of the ECJ decision.
The obligation to review final decisions exists in addition to, and independently of, the obligation to make good on damages caused by a national Supreme Court that misinterprets EC law without referring a question to the ECJ (see case C-224/01, Köbler).
Anno Rainer (arainer@deloitte.com), Brussels
Otmar Thoemmes (othoemmes@deloitte.de), Munich
Eric Tomsett (etomsett@deloitte.co.uk), London