IRS wins another LILO case but slips up in arguing economic substance

International Tax Review is part of Legal Benchmarking Limited, 1-2 Paris Garden, London, SE1 8ND

Copyright © Legal Benchmarking Limited and its affiliated companies 2026

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

Cookies Settings

IRS wins another LILO case but slips up in arguing economic substance

Joe Dalton
August 07 2013
john-hancock-logo-small.jpg

US life insurance company John Hancock has lost its Tax Court case concerning lease-in-lease-out (LILO) and sale-in-lease-out (SILO) transactions, meaning the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) continues its record of having won all cases on this issue. However, the IRS may have caused itself future difficulties by making an economic substance argument.

Unlock this content.

The content you are trying to view is exclusive to our subscribers.

To unlock this content:

Take a Free Trial or Login

Topics

NewsUnited StatesTax Disputes
JD
Joe Dalton
Contact
Joe Dalton worked at ITR between 2011 and 2013
more across site & shared bottom lb ros

More from across our site

Direct Tax
pillar two forum 2026 crowd shot.JPG
HMRC invites taxpayers to stress-test pillar two filings in ‘private beta’
The UK tax authority’s deputy director of large business also reassured taxpayers that HMRC will not ‘nitpick’ returns
Tom Baker, April 28 2026
David Beringer, Sucafina, ITR P2 Forum 2026.JPG
Pillar two a ‘box-ticking’ exercise, admits MNE tax head
Sucafina’s tax chief was speaking at the ITR Pillar 2 Forum in London alongside experts from HMRC and other organisations
Ed Conlon, April 28 2026
Direct Tax
India Supreme Court
Tiger Global ruling in India: scope, limits and risks
India’s Supreme Court rattled cross‑border structuring with its Tiger Global ruling. Subsequent rule changes narrowed the impact, but significant risks around GAAR, substance and treaty access persist
Ravish Bhatt, April 28 2026
Direct Tax
marc lien resized.jpg
Unity Advisory appoints AI chief as firm hits 100 employees
The UK-based big four spin-off firm has hired Marc Lien, who declared that most AI in professional services today is ‘cosmetic’
Sam Sholli, April 27 2026
Direct Tax
Pillar two is revising global tax competition with a 15% minimum tax rate
A taxing week: Brazil’s pillar two carve-out request prolongs a death by a thousand cuts
Projected revenue losses and exemption requests are harming the project’s capability and viability
Sam Sholli, April 24 2026
Indirect Tax
Prison
This week in tax: HMRC jails payroll fraudsters for 22 years
HMRC secured lengthy prison sentences in a major payroll VAT fraud case, while law firms announced tax promotions and hires
Tom Baker, April 24 2026
Transfer Pricing
Australian Company Tax Return concept
‘More refined’: advisers dissect updated ATO TP guidance
Significant changes include an update to profit markers and an alteration to how an ‘inbound distributor’ is defined
Sam Sholli, April 23 2026
Direct Tax
tim zech and jeff soar.png
AI in tax: from early promise to everyday reality
ITR sat down for a pre-event interview with Tim Zech, WTS Germany, and Jeff Soar, WTS UK, keynote speaker at next week’s ITR AI in Tax Forum 2026 in London
April 22 2026
Direct Tax
Brazil tax money
Brazil has ‘substantive grounds’ for pillar two carve-out request: advisers
Brazil’s bid to seek US-style exemptions from pillar two is ‘highly advantageous’ for multinationals, ITR has also heard
Sam Sholli, April 22 2026
Direct Tax
India expats regime
Tax certainty for non residents visiting India: unpicking recent reforms
India is signalling flexibility on expat taxation to attract foreign expertise, though employers will need to navigate disclosure, treaty and scope uncertainties
S Vasudevan, April 21 2026
Gift this article