By Erin Kelechava
The ratification of a new income tax treaty with the US and the approval by parliament of a Financial Bill brought some important changes for Italian taxpayers at the end of 2009.
The treaty is substantially similar to the proposed income tax treaty and protocol that the US Senate approved in 1999. The treaty is also generally consistent with the 2006 US model income tax treaty, although there are some significant differences.
Reduced withholding tax rates
The treaty provides for reduced withholding tax rates on dividends, royalties and interest. Treaty provisions introduce a limit of 5% on source country withholding tax on certain direct dividends and a limit of 15% on the same withholding tax on all other dividends.
The new provisions will also impose a limit of 5% on source country withholding tax on royalties paid for the use of computer software and industrial, commercial and scientific equipment.
The maximum permitted rate of withholding tax on interest is reduced from 15% to 10% under the new treaty. The treaty also eliminates withholding tax on interest paid to, guaranteed, or insured by qualified governmental entities and interest paid for a sale on credit of goods, merchandise, services or industrial, commercial or scientific equipment.
The new treaty will be in effect for taxable years beginning on or after January 1 2010, but the withholding tax provisions will have effect for new amounts paid or credited on or after February 1 2010.
Limitation of benefits clause
The treaty also contains an expanded limitation of benefits (LOB) provision which differs significantly from other recent US agreements.
Under article 2 of the protocol to the new treaty, a series of anti-abuse measures will include new tests to determine whether a resident company may be eligible for benefits under the treaty. The tests include the publicly-traded test, the subsidiary of a publicly-traded company test and the ownership and base erosion test which are all similar to the measures found in other US tax treaties.
However, although article 2 does not contain some of the most restrictive tests included in recent US tax treaties, neither does the LOB provision in the new treaty contain a derivative benefits provision. A derivative benefits extends treaty benefits to corporations that would not otherwise qualify under the LOB provision. In this case, a derivative benefits provision might have extended benefits to US or Italian companies that are owned by residents of countries that are EU member states or parties to NAFTA. The absence of this provision may lead some US or Italian resident companies to seek a ruling from their own competent authorities which would extend the benefits of the treaty to their companies.
"Although this LOB provision is typical in the US, this is unusual from an Italian perspective," says Maricla Pennesi, partner at the Milan office of DLA Piper.
Italian corporations are accustomed to LOB clauses, but the technical tests used to determine eligibility may initially confuse taxpayers. Pennesi notes similarities with other EU principles, which may provide some guidance for Italian companies that are unfamiliar with the complexities that accompany the technical definitions in the treaty.
"The definitions in the LOB provision may be close to the concept of a real beneficial owner that is common in European directives, which state that a company cannot have any entity that is interposed only for the purposes of benefiting from the treaty."
Italian 2010 financial bill
In another significant move for taxpayers, the Italian parliament approved its 2010 financial bill on December 22 2009.
"The most important tax issue contained in the bill is the voluntary step-ups that are being included," says Pennesi. "Corporate taxpayers will have the opportunity to pay a substitute tax on a voluntary basis both periodically and for extraordinary transactions, like mergers."