When Cisco forked out $3.2 billion for WebEx Communications, an online meeting company, traders thought that they had overpaid.
On March 15, the day before the deal was struck, WebEx's share price was $46.20, but Cisco offered $57 per share, a 23% premium. Nasdaq traders reacted to the news but cutting four cents off Cisco's trading price.
Innovation costs. And the premium can rise further when the high-tech target has mismanaged its innovations, causing needlessly high tax costs.
"When you're buying a technology company, their intangible property is a more significant part of the business," said Ron Schrotenboer, a tax partner at Fenwick & West office in Mountain View who represented Cisco and who has worked with several other high-tech firms.
Despite their significance, intangible assets such as intellectual property (IP) rights are often woefully mismanaged by technology start-ups.
And while proper management should be a priority from day one, high-tech companies often do not consider the structure that their IP ownership should take until too late down the line when a tax cost must be paid to turn the problem around. Rampant growth in a short amount of time can compound this problem.
Trouble in paradise
Schrotenboer emphasised that the acquirer must find out where the rights to the intangible assets are held.
"If a target holds the rights to its intangible assets in subsidiaries located outside the US, you have to look at whether they are in lower tax jurisdictions," Schrotenboer said.
|
Werner Heyvaert: No sane country will have tax treaties with tax havens |
"No sane country will have tax treaties with tax havens," said Werner Heyvaert, a tax partner at law firm Stibbe's Brussels office, "so if the intellectual property is held there, royalty payments will be subject to withholding tax."
To avoid this problem the target could allow the IP company located in the tax haven to grant a licence to a subsidiary set up in a jurisdiction such as, the Netherlands. The Netherlands has an extensive tax treaty network, plus favourable rules on royalty payments, such as no withholding tax on outbound payments and taxation on a relatively small margin between incoming and outgoing royalty payments.
The target should make sure that some of the value of its IP is added in the Netherlands. This added value could take the form of Dutch engineers adding value by installing software, or personalising the product.
Act now or pay later
If the acquiring company is looking at a target whose IP is mismanaged, then it can either arrange a restructuring pre-acquisition, or factor the cost of a post-acquisition restructuring into its pricing.
The lack of opportunity to amortise a product's value over time is another problem in technology acquisitions.
A company can lower its tax bill through amortisation by accounting for the depreciation of its intangible assets over time.
"When you develop a high-tech product, the costs of development become your tax base," said Heyvaert. "But when you start licensing a successful product, the fair market value will be substantially higher because of the value added by the product's innovativeness and the future cash-flow and royalty stream."
The fair market value will be represented in the target's share price. So a target's capitalisation could be $100 million, but it could have a tax base of $5 million.
The acquirer buying the company pays $95 million for goodwill in the company, for which it is impossible to calculate depreciation if the acquirer buys shares instead of assets.
Cost-sharing
Acquirers should also investigate whether cost sharing agreements are cross-border.
Cost sharing often takes place in technology firms to cover innovation costs, with other subsidiaries funding or lending money to the R&D department.
"It's not always obvious that cost sharing will be tax deductible in all the countries where the funding subsidiaries are located so you have to check the rules," said Heyvaert. "Also the authorities can get suspicious about the subsidiaries making large payments to the R&D centre, especially if it is located offshore, and the subsidiary has to be able to prove that it will get something in return."
Pillsbury Winthrop represented WebEx.