The emissions allowance recorded for Russia is around six billion tons of CO2 equivalent. This figure will probably be of considerable interest to potential investors. As an example of the potential of the Russian emissions-trading market, Sberbank, as an officially appointed Russian carbon units operator, recently approved the first joint implementation projects with a potential emission reduction of up to 40 million tons of CO2 equivalent, which is about €472 million ($616 million) in emission exchanges.
However, Russia does not have extensive practical experience in emissions trading and at the moment is still at the stage of legislative development. Market players are facing issues associated with practical implementation of the Kyoto Protocol's terms and mechanisms on this emerging market.
There are key VAT issues that need to be considered by market players involved in emissions trading in Russia – in particular, under Joint Implementation (JI) projects. There are many ambiguities in Russian civil and tax law in the treatment of Emission Reduction Units (ERUs) and transactions with ERUs. There is no legislative clarity on the mechanisms for transferring ERUs and the associated tax consequences. From a Russian VAT perspective, these important issues arise:
Is the registration of ERUs in the State Registry of Carbon Units a VATable event?
To what extent can domestic VAT place of supply rules be applied to a transfer of ERUs?
Is the transfer of ERUs to an investor subject to Russian VAT?
Joint Implementation projects
The Kyoto Protocol envisages two basic market instruments aimed at creating an economic incentive to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. These instruments are the Clean Development Mechanism (CDM) and Joint Implementation projects. The CDM is less relevant for Russian pollution makers, as it implies emission reductions by countries not mentioned in Annex I to the Kyoto Protocol, whereas Russia is included in this list. Only JI projects are relevant to this article.
The JI project mechanism envisaged by article 6 of the Kyoto Protocol is: in return for investment in a particular project aimed at the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions in another country, a country mentioned in Annex I to the Kyoto Protocol (Annex I Country) is entitled to emission allowances based on that project's emission reductions.
More specifically, Annex I Countries or companies on behalf of these countries are encouraged to implement emission reduction projects. These projects are then credited with ERUs, which can be used by another Annex I Country (Investor Country) or another company on behalf of the Investor Country for compliance with their own emission targets under the Kyoto Protocol. Upon completion of a JI project, an Annex I Country assigns the relevant quantity of ERUs to the company or companies from the Investor Country by making the relevant entry in the State Registry of Carbon Units.
Local legislative framework
Basically, Russian VAT law governs transactions with goods (works, services) and property rights only and is silent about transactions with ERUs. Considering the reference rule in domestic tax law, to assess the VAT implications of transactions with ERUs properly, it is first necessary to obtain a legal qualification of ERUs from a Russian civil law standpoint.
The results of the analysis show that ERUs are unknown from a legal perspective, and the Civil Code of the Russian Federation contains no clear and unambiguous definition of them. Russian lawyers and official bodies most often consider ERUs to be: (a) a kind of property right, (b) a security, (c) a financial service and (d) a sort of licence.
Based on a complex analysis of various oral and written opinions, the majority of lawyers experienced in the local market tend to treat ERUs as a kind of property right, since ERUs basically have all the key features of a property right. This approach seems to be the most appropriate, inasmuch as, in obtaining ERUs, a potential investor in a JI project acquires the right to emit a certain amount of greenhouse gases.
Other legal treatments of ERUs may be considered as well. In particular, ERUs are treated by some research as a sort of licence. A licence under Russian civil law constitutes special permission granted to the licensee by government bodies to perform certain types of operations or activities. From this perspective, ERUs might be also viewed as a result of the quantitative assessment of a JI project's implementation, as quantified and registered by authorised state bodies. However, the sale or assignment of a licence to a third party is generally not allowed. The official treatment of ERUs as a kind of free-circulating or quasi-licence is dubious.
Initial registration of ERUs in the State Registry of Carbon Units
Various approaches to the VAT treatment of the initial registration of ERUs may have different outcomes. Basically, however, a transaction is a VATable event only if goods (work, services) are sold or property rights are transferred.
Based on the fundamental principles of a JI project, ERUs in the State Registry of Carbon Units are initially assigned by the state (that is, the government or another authorised state authority). So if a transaction is treated as a sale or a transfer of a property right, the authorised state bodies would probably be regarded as the transferring party (seller), while a company implementing a JI project would be regarded as a recipient (buyer).
Russian tax law states that if a transaction subject to VAT is performed with state authorities which are not VAT payers, the buyer, acting as a tax agent, would be required to assess and pay the relevant amount of VAT in only a limited number of cases. In particular, the buyer would act as a tax agent in connection with the purchase or rental of any assets from the federal, regional or local government or administrative bodies. On the other hand, the Russian Tax Code specifically excludes all property rights from the definition of assets for tax purposes.
As mentioned before, ERUs could hardly be treated as an asset. On that basis, the initial registration of ERUs in the Russian State Registry of Carbon Units should have no VAT consequences for an investor in a JI project.
Subsequent transfer of ERUs
Russian VAT rules (for example, application of an exemption and place of supply rules) apply differently to various objects of civil rights. The strict and well-grounded legal treatment of ERUs is crucial for a proper assessment of the VAT consequences associated with their circulation in the market. There are potential VAT implications associated with the transfer of ERUs, considering the two previously mentioned options for their legal treatment.
ERUs as a kind of property right
As a general rule, the transfer of property rights in the territory of the Russian Federation is subject to VAT. There is no specific exemption for ERU transactions. The transfer of ERUs, as a kind of property right, should essentially be viewed as a transaction subject to VAT.
At the same time, domestic VAT law is based on the place of supply concept, that is, Russian VAT applies only to transactions regarded as performed in the territory of the Russian Federation. Considering that ERUs would likely be transferred to a foreign party, proper determination of the place of supply for the transfer of ERUs is of important. It is worth mentioning that VAT law does not contain a clear and generic definition of place of supply for all types of property rights; only minor cases are specifically covered.
In the clarifications of official bodies, the transfer of property rights is generally treated similarly to the provision of services. There are some grounds for regarding the place of supply rules for services as applicable to the transfer of property rights. Under the default place of supply rule, services are regarded as supplied in their seller's place of activity. The default rule should be applied to the provision of all types of services unless otherwise directly prescribed by law.
On these grounds, and considering that VAT place of supply rules contain no specific provisions about operations with ERUs, it is most likely that this transaction should be governed by the default rule. Given that it seems most appropriate to treat ERUs as a kind of property right, their transfer by Russian VAT payers should likely be regarded as performed in Russia and, therefore, as subject to VAT at the ordinary rate of 18%, irrespective of the buyer's origin.
ERUs as a quasi-licence
The treatment of ERUs as a quasi-licence is worth considering as well. Following such an approach may result in certain VAT benefits for a seller that is a Russian VAT payer.
The Russian Tax Code contains a special provision that the transfer of patents, copyrights, licences and other similar rights should be regarded as supplied in the buyer's place of activity. If ERUs are treated as other rights similar to a licence (a quasi-licence), their transfer by a company to which ERUs are initially assigned may come under this special rule and the relevant VAT implications would then depend mainly on the buyer's origin.
Consequently, where the recipient of ERUs, treated as a quasi-licence, is a foreign legal entity without any presence in Russia, such a transfer might be regarded as performed outside Russia and, so, as being outside the scope of Russian VAT. Again, the treatment of ERUs as a kind of free-circulating or quasi-licence is questionable and requires solid substantiation from a Russian civil law standpoint.
Position of the Russian Ministry of Finance
No official written clarifications of the Russian Ministry of Finance on the VAT implications of transactions with ERUs are publicly available. Ministry representatives have, however, on occasion spoken about this matter publicly.
The Ministry states that it does not regard the initial registration of ERUs in the State Registry of Carbon Units as subject to VAT. On the other hand, the subsequent transfer of ERUs is viewed as a transaction subject to VAT. In this regard, the Ministry tends to follow the most evident and easy approach and treat the transfer of ERUs as subject to the default place of supply rule, that is, ERUs are regarded for VAT purposes as supplied in the seller's place of activity. It is understood that the rationale behind this position is that the state regards the transfer of ERUs as potential additional income, since ERUs are likely to be purchased by foreign companies.
Double taxation
It follows on from this that the transfer of ERUs by Russian VAT payers to foreign investors would probably be subject to Russian VAT. In this regard, it is worth noting that many foreign jurisdictions apply an opposite place of supply"rule to operations with ERUs, meaning the buyer's place of activity may be regarded as the place of supply of ERUs. From a practical standpoint, such a different treatment of place of supply rules may potentially lead to double VAT taxation of the transactions in question: both in Russia and, for example, in the UK.
In response to the escalating threat of VAT fraud connected to the trading of emission allowances, some jurisdictions exempt ERU transactions from local VAT (with or without credit) or introduce a reverse charge mechanism. This may serve as a good planning opportunity for structuring ERU operations with Russian counteragents to increase a project's VAT efficiency. For example, if an investor in a JI project sets up a special purpose vehicle (SPV) in a jurisdiction where ERUs are not subject to VAT, this would potentially allow double VAT taxation to be avoided.
Legislative development perspectives
No final legislative initiatives on the taxation of operations with ERUs are believed to exist. However, the Ministry of Finance, in the recently published "Main Guidelines on the Development of Tax Policy for the Years 2011, 2012 and 2013", announced its intention to make innovations in tax law concerning operations with ERUs and the execution of JI projects.
It is hard to predict the general direction of upcoming changes, as there are no official publications on this matter or a concept of the draft law. Meanwhile, this situation is a good opportunity for all interested parties to consider the valuable EU experience in dealing with ERUs, especially concerning the application of, for example, VAT place of supply rules and VAT exemptions, and initiate a productive discussion with the Ministry.
If the contemplated amendments exempt ERU operations from VAT in one way or another, other VAT-related issues may arise, for example, the possibility of recovering VAT incurred on the implementation of a JI project.
Alexander Smirnov |
||
|
|
Ernst & Young Tax Partner Tel: +7 495 755 9848 Fax: +7 495 755 9701 Email: alexander.smirnov@ru.ey.com Alexander Smirnov is a partner in the tax & legal department of Ernst & Young in Moscow. He has more than 15 years of professional experience in performing and managing engagements involving operational restructuring of corporate groups in various industries; managing and participating in due diligence and audit engagements and providing business advisory services to clients in various industries. His list of clients includes major oil and gas, manufacturing and construction companies as well as large companies providing exploration and hydrocarbon production services. In 2010 Smirnov became head of the climate change tax group for the Commonwealth of Independent States. He has a PhD in economics. |
Alexei Matveev |
||
|
|
Ernst & Young Tel: +7 495 662 9325 Fax: +7 495 755 9701 Email: alexei.matveev@ru.ey.com Alexei Matveev is a director, tax & legal in the indirect tax group of Ernst & Young Moscow. He has more than 13 years of experience in Russian indirect and corporate tax matters, including indirect taxes. Matveev specialises in transaction tax and has served a large number of Russian and international companies and private equity funds, supporting them in M&A, including due diligence and tax structuring, advising on sale and purchase agreement-related matters and post-transaction support. He has gained significant experience in oil & gas and mining industries, retail, consumer products and industrial production. Before re-joining Ernst & Young he worked as deputy head of tax planning for TNK-BP responsible for the development of tax policies and procedures for this Russian oil & gas major. Matveev's major clients include Gazprombank, Sinopec, Severstal, ENI, Evraz, Arcelor Mittal, Sibur, Baring Vostok Capital Partners and Nexans. He has a degree in economics from Novosibirsk University. |
Anna Ryzhkova |
||
|
|
Ernst & Young Tel: +7 495 705 9700 Fax: +7 495 755 9701 Email: anna.ryzhkova@ru.ey.com Anna Ryzhkova is a tax & legal senior in the indirect tax and customs services department of Ernst & Young in Moscow. She has more than three years of experience in advising clients that include Russian and international real estate and telecommunications companies, and banks on indirect taxation. She is experienced in doing tax audits and due diligence of large Russian companies. Also, she has experience in dealing with the Russian tax inspectorate on behalf of clients. Recent consulting projects include development of the indirect tax position for transactions performed under the Kyoto Protocol, development of VAT methodology and accounting policy for a Russian metallurgic company for new legislation concerning derivatives and term transactions. In addition to previous big-four experience, she brings skills and knowledge she gained working as a chief accountant of a Russian microelectronics company. |