New York State Bar Association report on BEAT
International Tax Review is part of the Delinian Group, Delinian Limited, 4 Bouverie Street, London, EC4Y 8AX, Registered in England & Wales, Company number 00954730
Copyright © Delinian Limited and its affiliated companies 2024

Accessibility | Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Modern Slavery Statement

New York State Bar Association report on BEAT

Sponsored by

fenwick.jpg
New York Forum

Jim Fuller and David Forst examine the New York State Bar Association's latest analysis of the base erosion and anti-abuse tax (BEAT), which was introduced in the US tax reform.

In a previous column we identified a number of issues associated with the BEAT that operates under certain circumstances to reduce or deny the benefit of certain deductible payments made by a US taxpayer to a related foreign person. Since the writing of that column, the New York State Bar Association (NYSBA) issued a report on the BEAT and made a number of observations and recommendations. We highlight a few here.

The NYSBA has suggested that the Treasury should consider not treating payments as base eroding payments if they are made pursuant to certain transactions that are effectively conduit transactions. An example situation would be where a US person acts as a 'waystation' for transactions between two foreign related parties in a shared services context. Of course, existing anti-conduct principles could be applied even in the absence of any regulatory action, but it certainly would be helpful for regulations to confirm that conduit arrangements that are not fundamentally base eroding do not raise BEAT concerns.

The BEAT rules do not include the cost of goods sold (COGS) as base eroding payments, and Congress expressed a clear intent that COGS should not be treated as base eroding payments. Certain commentators, including the NYSBA, have observed that under certain circumstances COGS may include the value of intellectual property connected with the sale. The NYSBA stated that it does not recommend that the Treasury writes regulations limiting the scope of the COGS exception to payments that include the value of intellectual property. The report noted that Congressional intent was clear that COGS should not be treated as base eroding payments. Indeed, any such regulation would be contrary to Congressional intent.

The NYSBA recommended that the services cost method (SCM) exclusion be construed to mean that the actual cost element of SCM services be excludable from base erosion payments, irrespective of whether a markup on such services is charged (for example, because the foreign country's transfer pricing law requires a markup). This is a fair reading of the statute and Congressional intent, since in our view the exclusion focuses on the nature of the services performed and not the precise amount charged.

The NYSBA points to a possible statutory ambiguity regarding whether the base erosion percentage of any net operating loss (NOL) is determined with respect to the year of its origination or the year of its utilisation. The NYSBA said it believes that the correct grammatical read of the statute is that modified taxable income for the year is calculated without the relevant amount of NOL deduction allowed for the same year (therefore irrespective of the year in which the base erosion percentage of such NOL is determined). This reading also funds support from the context of the statute.

The NYSBA also recommended that the Treasury carve out an exception for payments made by a US shareholder to its controlled foreign corporation (CFC) when the payment is Subpart F income to the CFC.

more across site & bottom lb ros

More from across our site

Despite the relief, Brazil’s government has also presented a bill which seeks to re-impose a tax burden on companies’ payroll, one local tax specialist told ITR
Jeremy Brown arrives at the firm after a near 16-year career with Deloitte
PwC could elect a woman into the senior leadership position for the first time; in other news, KPMG Australia has extended its CEO’s term
The Senate report into PwC’s scandal is titled ‘The cover up worsens the crime’
Law firms that are conscious of their role in society are more likely to win work, according to a survey of over 23,000 in-house professionals
The firm’s tax business generated a quarter of HLB’s overall revenues in 2023
While successful pillar two implementation will require collaboration across all units, a combination of internal and external tax advice is at the centre of the effort
Binance has also been accused of manipulating foreign exchange rates via currency speculation and rate-fixing
Six individuals should have raised questions over information they received but did not breach professional standards, according to the firm
The partnership of KPMG UK has installed Holt for a second term as CEO and senior partner; in other news, a Baker McKenzie partner has sued the IRS
Gift this article